Skip to content

Tear off or recover: how to decide on a commercial roof

A recover costs a third less than a tear-off. Sometimes it is the right call and sometimes it is a mistake that fails in five years. Here is how we decide.

Mike Torres, Owner · October 15, 2025 · 5 min read

When a commercial roof reaches the end, the first question is whether the old roof has to come off. The answer is in the roof, not in the budget.

When a recover is allowed

Code allows one roof over another when the existing roof is a single layer, the insulation is dry, and the deck is sound. A building with two roofs already on it has to be torn off. So does one with wet insulation, because the water stays trapped under the new membrane and rots the deck.

How we find out

An infrared scan at night shows where the insulation is holding water: wet insulation holds heat longer and shows up warm. Core cuts confirm it and show what the layers are. This takes an evening and is included in every scope.

When recover is right

Dry, single-layer, sound deck, and the owner needs the cost advantage. A recover with a cover board and a new membrane gets a full manufacturer warranty and should last as long as the membrane.

When it is a mistake

Any wet insulation. A contractor who proposes a recover without a scan is guessing with your deck.

The honest number

On our scopes over the last three years, about 40% of roofs qualified for a recover. The other 60% had wet insulation, two layers, or a deck problem. The scan decided every one.

A recover over wet insulation is a roof that fails in five years and a deck that fails in eight.
Next step

Tell us about the roof. We will walk it, scan it and send a scope with photos.

A Ridgeline estimator replies the same business day. Program clients reach a foreman on the 24-hour line, any time.

Demonstration site. Ridgeline Roofing is a fictional company. Designed and built by Ironsite Digital to show what a commercial roofing contractor's website should be. Want one like it?